|
|
Post by williamwes626 on Sept 12, 2022 9:53:45 GMT -5
This is my reality on Xbox with pro difficulty I’m using a purple Hogan driver, yellow fairway and hybrid and all silver irons and wedges for accuracy. I basically have one polling point in that white perfect quadrant with no leeway for a slight miss hit in the white area. If I hit a perfect it’s always in the exact same place wether I’m hitting driver or the much more forgiving irons. The next few images starting with the driver feedback goes down to irons and a pitching wedge. You will notice the perfect line is in the exact same position on all of them, I think HB have hoodwinked us into thinking that we have a better chance of a perfect even when they’ve given us a bigger ark. Now that would be true if they give us more polling points across that white arc but they haven’t, I either get a perfect in that exact same place or I get a grey fast or slow at best for a slightly off tempo shot. I don’t know if PS are seeing the exact same thing or do they get perfects right across the arc in different areas. You will notice I do have leeway with my swing plane but we know that has less effect on the accuracy of your shot than tempo. Edit: I’ve worked out that I have the same chance hitting a perfect with the purple driver that gives more distance than with a silver one that gives less so I might as well be further up the hole and thus nearer the green. Driver  Medium irons    Wedge  I wasn't going to chime in but you were saying you only have one perfect polling point but I see the driver example is different from the others. The driver polling point you posted is exactly in the middle of the perfect white zone, and the other club examples are in the right side of the perfect white zone. So you have at least two polling points within the white perfect. If you have one in the middle and one on the right, you may also have one in the left side of the perfect. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 12, 2022 10:36:44 GMT -5
Do you play the game at 60Hz or 30hz? I say this as I think this is a game that needs a stable framerate, especially on Master/legend, yes a 60fps VSync cap is good but not if your frames dip below 60 fps consistently. A PS5 shouldn't have problems but the PS4 and PS4 Pro cannot keep a steady 60 fps. Some courses play well others like crap on PS Pro and I do believe that frame rate issues can effect tempo. 60. Most of the time it looks P smooth on screen, on 30 it looked a bit stuttered. It's still strange how there were virtually no glitches all season on pro then suddenly a whole heap in one week on master. If it plays like it did today it's fine, last week was just frustrating. The thing is the game wasn't designed for 60fps framerates on the last gen consoles. That was patched in later and I just think the framerate are too inconsistent on my PS Pro on some courses, one of the reasons I don't really play the game on that console and I just can't do a fixed 30fps. Yes pro difficulty does seem extremely forgiving especially on the golf clubs I use. But as others have complained about I am not going to change every club in my bag to purple just to play 4 rounds on TST each week. Also I do use purple driver and driving just seem way too easy, it is more where you aim rather than any kind of realistic punishment for what I would call poor tempo. I have played master since release and I think it is a pretty good skill level that plays consistently on my PC with a DS4 and the clubs I use. Would be happy with a similar set up on 2K23 but with a little more distance. |
|
|
|
Post by martbloke on Sept 12, 2022 15:41:09 GMT -5
It certainly could depend on calibration although that still wouldn't make a lot of sense. If others can hit more than 1 spot, then those on the same console should be able to as well. You may find that you are just more consistent than you think when it comes to perfect tempo haha 😜 But what I do agree with is that everyone across all platforms should be able to hit any number of positions within a zone let alone the entire semi circle. If it's capped because of this polling thing, then that's not great for gamers and HB need to work the solution to make it so even if it means a slightly different build between platforms to get the same results. Would you say your calibrated tempo is a slower or faster tempo? I have a feeling that the faster your tempo the less accurate the game's reading for tempo with Xbox. It makes sense as an Xbox reads the controller input 124 times a second, so the quicker the stick movement the more rounding off to certain finishing spots. A 1000 times per second mouse for example will give a much more accurate reading of tempo and little to none rounding off with finishing spots. I would definitely say mine is on the slower side. Smooth and steady. I prefer a slower swing in this game so I feel if I do actually swing too fast moreso than slows as slows are easy to identify. |
|
junuh5
Caddy
Posts: 20
Tour: Elite
|
Post by junuh5 on Sept 12, 2022 21:50:57 GMT -5
I just want to say that I hope platinum and elite go to a master setting in the new game. I don't even know if the difficulty setting will be the same. The argument that it is unfair to Xbox players because of the tempo cannot be made in the new game. As I have heard, there will be a 3-click option in the new game. Therefore, Xbox players could use the 3-click option and be on the same level as Playstation players. But, I know very little about the new game so I am speculating. Anyway, I love TGC Tours and will be playing regardless.
|
|
|
|
Post by jeseterr on Sept 13, 2022 1:02:16 GMT -5
I just want to say that I hope platinum and elite go to a master setting in the new game. I don't even know if the difficulty setting will be the same. The argument that it is unfair to Xbox players because of the tempo cannot be made in the new game. As I have heard, there will be a 3-click option in the new game. Therefore, Xbox players could use the 3-click option and be on the same level as Playstation players. But, I know very little about the new game so I am speculating. Anyway, I love TGC Tours and will be playing regardless. I'm an Xbox player and I think that no one cares about this 3 click system. If you play with joystick, it is more similar as a golf swing. 3 click is not at all. But yesterday I changed my clubs and now I can play around par with Master settings. It is much better. I ¨m CCL player |
|
|
|
Post by lessangster on Sept 13, 2022 3:10:39 GMT -5
There are people on Xbox that wanted three click and thats fair enough that they have given them what they asked for personally I won’t use it, I think three click should be left in the past where it belongs but that’s just my opinion .
|
|
|
|
Post by jeseterr on Sept 13, 2022 3:13:11 GMT -5
There are people on Xbox that wanted three click and thats fair enough that they have given them what they asked for personally I won’t use it, I think three click should be left in the past where it belongs but that’s just my opinion . You are true !!! |
|
|
|
Post by MrQueez on Sept 13, 2022 7:41:09 GMT -5
I just want to say that I hope platinum and elite go to a master setting in the new game. I don't even know if the difficulty setting will be the same. The argument that it is unfair to Xbox players because of the tempo cannot be made in the new game. As I have heard, there will be a 3-click option in the new game. Therefore, Xbox players could use the 3-click option and be on the same level as Playstation players. But, I know very little about the new game so I am speculating. Anyway, I love TGC Tours and will be playing regardless. I'm an Xbox player and I think that no one cares about this 3 click system. If you play with joystick, it is more similar as a golf swing. 3 click is not at all. But yesterday I changed my clubs and now I can play around par with Master settings. It is much better. I ¨m CCL player I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Most of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. |
|
|
|
Post by jeseterr on Sept 13, 2022 7:51:33 GMT -5
I'm an Xbox player and I think that no one cares about this 3 click system. If you play with joystick, it is more similar as a golf swing. 3 click is not at all. But yesterday I changed my clubs and now I can play around par with Master settings. It is much better. I ¨m CCL player I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Nost of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. Yes, I remember EA game series TW PGA TOUR. There was an option 3click. |
|
|
|
Post by MrQueez on Sept 13, 2022 9:19:28 GMT -5
I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Nost of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. Yes, I remember EA game series TW PGA TOUR. There was an option 3click. I remember my 1st CD-ROM PGA Tour Pro in the early 90's. It came with a 2nd disk that had Pebble Beach and a couple of other courses. I tried to load it up on my old laptop 2 years ago, but it was not compatible. I think I might have tossed it away by mistake  |
|
|
|
Post by martbloke on Sept 13, 2022 12:39:56 GMT -5
I'm an Xbox player and I think that no one cares about this 3 click system. If you play with joystick, it is more similar as a golf swing. 3 click is not at all. But yesterday I changed my clubs and now I can play around par with Master settings. It is much better. I ¨m CCL player I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Most of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. I'd be very surprised if 60%+ of buyers chose 3 click as their default control option over analogue. That's a very high number. Don't get me wrong I will try it to see how it plays but it won't be my default that's for sure. Analogue to me, is more immersive than click a button 3 times. Also, the putting is just fantastic in this game so I don't want to remove that from my experience. If tempo is broken then possibly it may get to 40% but I don't expect much higher. |
|
|
|
Post by lessangster on Sept 13, 2022 13:07:02 GMT -5
I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Most of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. I'd be very surprised if 60%+ of buyers chose 3 click as their default control option over analogue. That's a very high number. Don't get me wrong I will try it to see how it plays but it won't be my default that's for sure. Analogue to me, is more immersive than click a button 3 times. Also, the putting is just fantastic in this game so I don't want to remove that from my experience. If tempo is broken then possibly it may get to 40% but I don't expect much higher. I love the putting in this game I hope they don’t ruin it in the new one. It’s the best I’ve ever had in any golf game and that includes the TW games, three click would take away that feeling for me. Like many of you I will give it a go but I can’t see me sticking with it. |
|
|
|
Post by MrQueez on Sept 13, 2022 13:19:02 GMT -5
I would not be surprised at all if 60%+ of people that buy 2k23 use 3-click. I'm on pc waiting for a new game and was happy to hear 3-click would be an option. Most of the golf games I've played over the last 30 years were 3-click or something similar. I'm looking forward to playing both 3-click and analog. I'd be very surprised if 60%+ of buyers chose 3 click as their default control option over analogue. That's a very high number. Don't get me wrong I will try it to see how it plays but it won't be my default that's for sure. Analogue to me, is more immersive than click a button 3 times. Also, the putting is just fantastic in this game so I don't want to remove that from my experience. If tempo is broken then possibly it may get to 40% but I don't expect much higher. Whatever the percentage ends up being it will be much higher than percentage of people that do analog. If you add the swing meter with the 3-click the percentage could be 90%+ |
|
|
|
Post by lessangster on Sept 13, 2022 14:11:59 GMT -5
All you guys looking forward to the three click swing in 2K23 how can you replicate the feel of this type of putt using that control method. This 66 foot putt was all feel, no moving the marker, unfortunately I missed the start but you get the result.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kie on Sept 13, 2022 14:33:53 GMT -5
It's worth noting that, based on how Apexhound and Crazy Canuck have described it, the three click swing isn't exactly as we have seen it before in the likes of Rory McIlroy's golf and many games before it. It sounds like it is a modern day incarnation which might have some merit as an alternative swing mechanism. Whilst I will probably stick with analogue swing, I certainly welcome the addition of an alternative swing mechanism in the game and I'm looking forward to trying it out on 11th October.
|
|
